We Lose When B.C. Government Listens To Bond Raters Over Citizens

Susan Lambert  Susan Lambert     Past President, B.C. Teachers’ Federation

http://www.huffingtonpost.ca    05/05/2014

Peter Cameron’s warnings that the economic skies of B.C. will fall should government negotiate a fair contract for B.C.’s teachers reminded me of Doug Foster’s testimony in the historic court case won by the B.C. Teachers’ Federation this spring.

Foster, assistant deputy finance minister and unabashed fervent apostle of “free market” based economic policy, testified that the province invites bond raters to advise as provincial budgets are developed. That advice is designed to “keep taxes low and constrain spending” in return for a good credit rating.

Foster testified the bond raters are wary of all spending, including capital projects, and are staunchly opposed to deficit budgets. The net zero mandate was approved of by these raters who promised to maintain the triple AAA rating only with the caution that the mandate be maintained.

Foster also testified that government agreed with the raters that the economy was fragile, even though this analysis was contradicted in the government’s message to the people of B.C.

Colin Hansen, the finance minister at the time, painted a rosy picture of the economy in the province, talking about B.C. as one of the strongest leaders in economic growth in Canada attributable to the success of the Olympics, the ability to pay down the debt by $9 billion, and projections of personal income increases of three to four per cent among other favourable indicators.

So Cameron’s warnings connect some economic dots for me. Seems like the bond raters, firms like Standard and Poors found to be complicit in the 2008 global economic crisis, are once again “advising” government. These are the people in favour of an alternative vision of Canada, (one in which the 1% have both economic and political clout and can dictate policies that increase the numbers of homeless, impoverished and dispirited in an increasingly mean world), who are coercing our government with the financial equivalent of the fabled carrot and stick.

Rather than charting our own course as citizens of this province and probably this country, we are being held to ransom by the rogues and villains who profit from low taxes, smaller government and free markets.

These are the greedy charlatans who preach “trickle down” economics and promote private rather than public services. Who are supported by corporations with production and supply lines in Bangladesh where there are no regulations or unions to protect workers from exploitation, violation and death in order to profit when these goods are sold for enormous returns here in B.C.

And what effect has this “free market” driven economic policy had on public services in this province? You don’t have to look further than your local school board struggling to identify yet further cuts to the programs and services that once made the system the strongest in the world.

We have the highest child poverty rate in the country. Mary Ellen Turpel Lafond has recently revealed that we have, across the province, fewer services for children than there are in the city of Calgary.

As this government heeds the advice of free market economists, so does our investment in public services decline. These neo-liberal economic policies are supposed to be beneficial for all, but we see the stark reversal of that promise.

The hope of jobs is fading as the promise is pushed further and further back on the horizon. Public services are declining. And costs to ordinary citizens are increasing. When will we ever learn?

Follow Susan Lambert on Twitter: www.twitter.com/susant8404

IBEW 213 & COPE 378 Locked Out FortisBC Workers Rally Held In Trail B.C.

December 7, 2013   By Andrew Chernoff, West Kootenay Labour Council

TRAIL-IBEW 213 and COPE 378 locked out FortisBC workers, labour and community supporters along with distinguished dignitaries gathered at the FortisBC office in downtown Trail, B.C. on December 7, 2013.

Jim Sinclair (right), president of the BC Federation of Labour addressing locked out FortisBC workers and their supporters at rally in Trail on December 7, 2013. Armiindo deMedeiros (left) president of USW 480.                                                                                                                                                              Jim Sinclair, president BC Federation of Labour speaking at support rally for locked  out FortisBC workers in Trail B.C. on December 7, 2013.

Those at the rally braved wind and cold temperatures as cold as –16 degrees Celsius, listening todistinguished speakers demanding that FortisBC do what it did with COPE 378 FortisBC inside workers last week——bargain in good faith a new and fair collective agreement—–and end the six month lock out imposed by them on June 26.

Speaker after speaker…….

  • Jim Sinclair, president of the BC Federation of Labour;
  • David Black, president of COPE 378;
  • Katrina Conroy, NDP MLA Kootenay West;
  • Susan Lambert, past president of the B.C. Teachers Federation;
  • Andy Davidoff, president of the Kootenay-Columbia Teachers’ Union;
  • Rod Russell, IBEW 213 business manager
  • Armindo deMedeiros, president USW 480

—–all encouraging locked out FortisBC workers to continue standing their ground.

The speakers also appealed to FortisBC locked out worker supporters in the community and the House of Labour, to continue demanding FortisBC do the respectful and dignified thing: sit down and negotiate in good faith a new and fair collective agreement, and end this lockout that is now in its sixth month.

Unless a Grinch’s heart grows, this story of 225 locked out electrical workers won’t have a very merry ending. The latest round of negotiations between FortisBC and its electrical workers failed earlier in the week; all but ensuring the workers will be locked out for the holiday season.

Two days of talks broke off on December 5, 2013 with no end in sight for the nearly six month lockout that began on June 26.

For 225 workers across the southern interior who haven’t seen a paycheque in six months, Christmas is going to be really tough. For FortisBC which has saved over $7 million dollars and is only raising rates another 19% by 2018, obviously Christmas doesn’t matter much. Except of course for its CEO, who will take in another $1.4 million this year. He’ll certainly be jolly, while his workers are freezing and his customers are paying more.

Since locking out its electrical employees FortisBC has continued to only add requirements for a deal to be done. Negotiations collapsed today because the company will not budge from two significant demands: a mandatory compressed work week which entails longer working days for less money, and the Union’s surrender of its legal right to labour action in the System Control Centre.

After suffering six months without pay, the Union wanted its members back to work so at least Christmas could be a happy time spent with their family. Seeking to be flexible, three proposals were brought to the table. One was the same, identical deal FortisBC signed yesterday with COPE 378, its office workers, and the company said no. The second proposal was a basic, plain back-to-work agreement, that included only minimal wage increases of 2.5%-2%-2%-2.5%-2.5%, no other changes, and the company said no.

An IBEW 213 statement released after talks broke off on Thursday, stated:

Though it would be hard for workers with young families, the third proposal included a compromise on the mandatory compressed work week. All workers would be forced to be on the compressed work week if 50%+1 of the crew voted for it or if 75% of the workers’ headquarters voted for it. The company had already agreed to a 5% premium as compensation for working the longer 10 hour day which would significantly encourage workers to vote for it. However FortisBC rejected this compromise.

If these demands of a compressed work week and giving up right to strike were so important for FortisBC, why didn’t the company bring them up earlier? Why did FortisBC only make these demands months after its workers were locked out? It would appear FortisBC isn’t interested in a deal or compromise; it just wants its workers locked out until FortisBC can get whatever it wants.”

More pictures of rally:

David Black, Sean Smith, Stephanie Smith At FortisBC Locked Out Workers Rally In Trail, B.C. on December 7, 2013Kootenay-Columbia Teachers' Union Supporting FortisBC Locked Out Workers At Rally in Trail on December 7, 2013Nelson District Teachers Association and BCGEU union members supporting FortisBC Locked Out Workers At Rally in Trail on Decemb er 7, 2013Susan Lambert, former BCTF President Supporting FortisBC Locked Out Worker At Rally in Trail on December 7, 2013Armindo deMedeiros, USW 480 President speaker at rally in support of FortisBC locked out workers in Trail on December 7, 2013Supporters of locked out FortisBC workers, and locked out FortisBC workers at rally in Trail on December 7, 2013 to get public support to have FortisBC end lockout.Rally in Trail supporting locked out FortisBC workers on December 7, 2013Armindo deMedeiros (left) and Katrine Conroy NDP MLA Kootenay West at rally supporting locked out FortisBC workers in Trail on December 7, 2013.David Black (right) COPE 378 president addressing rally in support of locked out FortisBC workers on December 7, 2013 in Trail B.C. Armindo deMedeiros (left) USW 480 president.Rocco Mastrubono, president CUPE Local 339-Nelson Civic in Trail on December 7, 2013 supporting locked out FortisBC workers at rally.Andy Davidoff, president Kootenay-Columbia Teachers' Union  preparing to speak at rally in support of locked out FortisBC workers in Trail B.C. on Decemb er 7, 2013. Armindo deMedeiros (left) lets out a laugh as Davidoff prepares to speak.Locked out FortisBC workers at their rally in Trail B.C. on December 7, 2013 listening to speakers demanding FortisBC negotiate new collective agreement and return locked out IBEW 213 and COPE 378 workers back to work.Rod Russell IBEW 213 business manager speaking at rally in support of locked out FortisBC workers in Trail B.C. on December 7, 2013.Susan Lambert, former BCTF president bringing greetings from current BCTF presidednt Jim Iker and addressing rally in support of locked out FortisBC workers in Trail B.C. on December 7, 2013.