Matein Khalid http://www.khaleejtimes.com October 26, 2015
The Canadian dollar’s strength may not last.(AFP)
Even though Trudeau is the son of a political legend Pierre Trudeau, he has no economic or diplomatic policy making experience.
So justin Pierre Trudeau is the new Premier Ministre of Canada. Stephen Harper’s decade in power as the Tory grand vizier in Ottawa was ultimately doomed by the oil shock, the commodities bust, the 2015 Canadian recession and voter discontent in Ontario, Quebec, Alberta and the Atlantic seaboard states. Even though Trudeau is the son of a political legend Pierre Trudeau, he has no economic or diplomatic policy making experience. Yet he will rule the first Liberal majority government in Ottawa since Jean Chretien in the late 1990s.
I can envisage higher public spending as Trudeau (and the electorate) does not share the Conservative Party’s commitment to a balanced budget or a Canadian combat role in the US led military coalition against Daesh in Iraq. This means tensions with Washington beyond the Keystone XL pipeline issue. Trudeau could even resurrect the ghost of his father’s Third Option in a world where China and Russia both challenge the US. All this reinforces my conviction, outlined in my October 12 KT column, that the Canadian dollar’s strength will not last.
So it did not surprise me that the loonie fell against 15 major currencies in Singapore trading the night Trudeau unseated Harper and entered the world stage. Once the Tories resorted to the xenophobic, anti-niqab campaign, I knew Harper had run out of ideas and political risk was going to rise in Canada even as oil prices and economic growth rates/mining capex fell. Trudeau’s C$60 billion infrastructure pledge (funded rise in deficits) and two shock Bank of Canada rate cuts, fiscal populism and higher US economic momentum means a lower loonie. So does the monetary policy divergence between the Yellen Fed and the Poloz Bank of Canada I expect will widen in 2016.
As a personal friend of former Liberal Prime Minister Jean Chretien and father of (a UAE dirham-financed) McGill undergrad, I will not disguise my pleasure at the election result and the softness of the Canadian dollar. Yet the free-fall in the Canadian dollar began in spring 2014 under the conservatives, when I recommended a loonie short at 1.06 (or 94 cents) against the US dollar.
Justin Trudeau will only add fiscal stimulus to Governor Poloz’s ultra-dovish monetary policies which have failed to use loonie depreciation to revive the Canadian economy. The yield on the 10-year Canadian Government bond is a miniscule 1.46 per cent at a time when Canada’s federal and provincial debt burden will only rise. In any case, the oil shock and $500 billion reserve falls in China will force sovereign wealth funds to jettison their holdings of Canadian government debt, which has historically been correlated with a rise in Federal budget deficits. A strategic put option on Canadian dollar government debt makes total sense since the yield on the 10-year Uncle Canuck note could well rise to two per cent or higher by late spring. Does Justin Trudeau’s proposed fiscal stimulus threaten Canada’s AAA credit rating? No.
Canada had the stablest banking system in the Western world in 2008 while Wall Street, the City of London and even the Bahnofstrasse/Paradeplatz went ballistic on subprime debt/credit derivatives. The commodity supercycle and China’s spectacular economic growth since 2001 was a financial windfall for Canada. Yet that was then and this is now. Canada is now in near recession, the commodities bust has just begun, epic consumer debt presages a housing crash, energy loans will gut banking profits and the loonie hit 12-year lows in September. Even though Alberta oil sands boast the world’s third-largest oil reserves, they are high-cost marginal producers who are toast during a global oil glut with no swing producer in either Riyadh or West Texas/North Dakota. Paradoxically, Harper’s “energy superpower” boast now haunts the loonie, since oil and gas is 25 per cent of Canadian exports. Other than the Norwegian kroner, the Canadian dollar is the ultimate Western world petrocurrency now, the political pendulum has shifted back from Alberta to the Liberal bastions of West Montreal.